10 Best We Did It Alternatives for Nonprofits

Why Look for a We Did It Alternative?

We Did It (WeDid.It) provides a simple, no-subscription fundraising platform where nonprofits pay only when they raise money. Campaign pages, P2P fundraising, team pages, and social sharing tools cover the basics for small organizations that cannot justify monthly software fees. But limitations become apparent as fundraising programs grow, pushing organizations to explore We Did It alternatives.

High effective cost at scale. We Did It charges approximately 5% platform fees on top of standard credit card processing fees (roughly 2.9% plus $0.30). The combined 7 to 8% effective cost per donation works for small campaigns but becomes expensive quickly. An organization raising $200,000 annually pays $14,000 to $16,000 in combined fees, more than most subscription platforms would cost.

Limited feature depth. We Did It covers basic campaign pages and P2P fundraising. There is no built-in CRM, no email marketing tools, no event management, no auction capability, and no advanced donor segmentation. Organizations needing anything beyond simple campaign pages must maintain separate tools.

No recurring giving infrastructure. While donors can set up recurring gifts, the platform lacks card updater, smart retry on failed payments, and donor self-service portals. Organizations building monthly giving programs find the recurring tools insufficient for reducing churn and retaining recurring donors.

Basic customization. Campaign pages offer limited design control. Organizations wanting branded donation experiences with custom CSS, embeddable forms, or developer API access find the customization options constraining.

Smaller platform ecosystem. We Did It has fewer third-party integrations, a smaller user community, and less extensive support resources compared to established competitors. Organizations scaling their fundraising technology stack may find integration gaps.

If your nonprofit has outgrown simple campaign pages, needs stronger recurring giving, wants lower effective fees at scale, or requires CRM and event capabilities, these alternatives provide meaningful upgrades.

What to Consider When Choosing a Campaign Platform

Before evaluating alternatives, clarify what your fundraising needs have outgrown versus what We Did It provides.

Total cost modeling. Calculate your current effective cost with We Did It's percentage-based fees. Compare against subscription models at your annual volume. Many subscription platforms become cheaper than We Did It above $50,000 in annual donations.

Feature consolidation. Identify how many separate tools you use alongside We Did It. Platforms with built-in CRM, email, and event tools may reduce total cost by replacing multiple subscriptions. Factor in employee training time when evaluating consolidated platforms.

Recurring giving priority. If monthly giving is becoming significant, investment in dedicated recurring infrastructure with card updater and retry logic pays for itself through reduced churn.

Integration requirements. Evaluate whether alternatives connect to your CRM, email platform, and accounting software through native connections or a robust integration ecosystem.

Campaign versus year-round needs. Determine whether you need campaign-focused tools or year-round fundraising infrastructure. Some alternatives specialize in campaigns while others provide comprehensive daily giving tools.

10 Best We Did It Alternatives

These platforms range from free options to enterprise solutions. Each addresses specific We Did It limitations while serving different scales and strategies.

1. Givebutter

Overview

Givebutter provides the most direct upgrade from We Did It. Zero platform fees through a tip-based model with broader features including donation forms, crowdfunding, P2P, event ticketing, livestream fundraising, and a built-in CRM. The cost advantage over We Did It's 5% platform fee is immediate and significant.

Core Capabilities

- Donation forms embeddable on any website

- Crowdfunding campaigns with progress meters

- Peer-to-peer fundraising with team pages

- Event ticketing and registration

- Livestream fundraising integration

- Built-in CRM with donor profiles and communication

- Text-to-give functionality

- Recurring giving management

- Social media sharing optimization

- Integration with Salesforce, Mailchimp, QuickBooks, and Zapier

Standout Strength

Zero platform fees with dramatically broader features than We Did It. The built-in CRM alone eliminates the need for a separate donor management tool, and the cost savings over We Did It's 5% fee are substantial at any donation volume.

Best For

Any nonprofit currently paying We Did It's percentage fees that wants more features at lower cost. The most obvious upgrade path from We Did It for organizations at any scale.

Pricing Overview

- Zero platform fees (tip-based model)

- Standard Stripe processing fees apply

- Free tier available

- Pro features on paid plans

Limitations

- The tip-based model depends on donor willingness to tip.

- Enterprise features less developed than premium platforms.

- Less established with large organizations.

Quick Comparison Insight

More features at lower effective cost than We Did It. The most natural transition for organizations seeking both savings and capability upgrades.

2. Donorbox

Overview

Donorbox provides the comprehensive feature upgrade from We Did It's basic campaign tools. Embeddable donation forms, strong recurring giving with card updater and retry logic, crowdfunding, P2P, event ticketing, and text-to-give. The recurring giving infrastructure directly addresses We Did It's weakest area.

Core Capabilities

- Embeddable donation forms with customizable branding

- Recurring giving with automatic card updater and retry logic

- Crowdfunding campaign pages

- Peer-to-peer fundraising pages

- Event registration and ticketing

- Text-to-give for live events

- Support for Stripe, PayPal, ACH, Apple Pay, and Google Pay

- Integration with Salesforce, Mailchimp, QuickBooks, and Zapier

- Donor management with giving history

- Membership management

Standout Strength

The strongest recurring giving infrastructure among alternatives. Card updater and retry logic retain monthly donors that simpler platforms lose. For organizations building monthly giving programs, this capability alone justifies the switch from We Did It.

Best For

Nonprofits prioritizing recurring giving growth. The comprehensive upgrade from We Did It with the strongest monthly donor retention tools available.

Pricing Overview

- Free plan (1.75% platform fee)

- Pro at $139 per month (1.5% platform fee)

- Standard processing fees apply

- No long-term contracts

Limitations

- Per-transaction platform fees still apply.

- More complex setup than We Did It.

- Fee structure requires cost comparison at your volume.

Quick Comparison Insight

Comprehensive fundraising upgrade with the strongest recurring giving tools. The cost may be lower than We Did It's 5% at higher volumes.

3. GiveLively

Overview

GiveLively offers genuinely free fundraising for verified 501(c)(3) organizations. Zero platform fees, zero subscription charges. For qualifying organizations currently paying We Did It's 5% fee, GiveLively eliminates platform costs entirely while providing comparable campaign functionality.

Core Capabilities

- Online donation forms

- Peer-to-peer fundraising campaigns

- Event registration with ticketing

- Text-to-give

- Recurring donation management

- Social sharing tools

- Donor management with giving history

- Embeddable donation widgets

- Custom campaign pages with progress tracking

- Integration with major CRM platforms

Standout Strength

Completely free for 501(c)(3) nonprofits. The most dramatic cost reduction from We Did It's percentage-based model, saving organizations thousands annually in platform fees while providing comparable analytics.

Best For

501(c)(3) nonprofits wanting to eliminate platform fees entirely. The maximum cost savings transition from We Did It for qualifying organizations.

Pricing Overview

- Zero platform fees for 501(c)(3) organizations

- Standard Stripe processing fees (approximately 2.2% plus $0.30)

- Optional donor tip supports the platform

- No paid tiers

Limitations

- Only available to verified 501(c)(3) organizations.

- Basic feature depth similar to We Did It.

- Sustainability questions around the free model.

Quick Comparison Insight

Free alternative eliminating We Did It's platform fees entirely. Restricted to 501(c)(3) organizations but saves significantly.

4. MightyCause

Overview

MightyCause provides a free tier with fundraising tools plus a nonprofit directory for donor discovery. The combination of basic fundraising at low cost with built-in audience access creates a differentiated alternative to We Did It's isolated campaign pages.

Core Capabilities

- Hosted donation pages

- P2P fundraising campaigns

- Nonprofit directory and donor discovery

- Recurring giving management

- Event-linked fundraising

- Team fundraising

- Donor management

- Social sharing tools

- Embeddable widgets

- Employer matching integration

Standout Strength

The nonprofit directory creates organic donor discovery that We Did It and most alternatives do not offer. Built-in audience access supplements existing donor acquisition through peer-based community discovery.

Best For

Small nonprofits seeking low-cost tools with built-in donor discovery. The directory-enhanced alternative when acquiring new donors matters as much as managing existing campaigns.

Pricing Overview

- Free plan available

- Paid plans from around $59 per month

- Per-transaction fees on free tier

- Reduced fees on paid plans

Limitations

- Feature depth comparable to We Did It's basic level.

- Directory discovery is competitive.

- Limited customization.

Quick Comparison Insight

Comparable basic tools with donor directory addition. The right switch when donor discovery creates more value than We Did It provides.

5. CauseVox

Overview

CauseVox specializes in P2P fundraising with campaign microsites, fundraiser coaching, gamification, and team management. For organizations where peer-to-peer campaigns drive significant revenue, CauseVox provides P2P depth that We Did It's basic team pages cannot approach.

Core Capabilities

- Branded P2P campaigns with individual and team pages

- Campaign microsites with progress tracking

- Donation forms with recurring giving

- Fundraiser coaching toolkit

- Event-linked campaigns

- Dashboards and leaderboards

- Built-in donor CRM

- Gamification features

- Salesforce and Mailchimp integrations

- Multi-campaign management

Standout Strength

Dedicated P2P campaign management with coaching tools and gamification features. The built-in CRM consolidates fundraising and donor management, replacing both We Did It and a separate CRM tool.

Best For

Nonprofits with active P2P programs outgrowing We Did It's basic team pages. The P2P specialist when supporter-driven campaigns justify dedicated tools.

Pricing Overview

- Starting around $200 per month

- Scales with features and volume

- Free trial available

Limitations

- P2P focused, not a general platform.

- Significant cost increase from We Did It.

- Requires additional tools for other channels.

Quick Comparison Insight

P2P depth We Did It cannot match. The subscription cost is justified when P2P revenue exceeds the savings on We Did It's percentage model.

6. Classy

Overview

Classy represents the enterprise upgrade from We Did It. Now part of GoFundMe, Classy provides donation pages, P2P, events, crowdfunding, and recurring giving with professional campaign management and comprehensive analytics. For organizations that have outgrown simple campaign tools entirely.

Core Capabilities

- Branded donation pages with templates

- P2P fundraising with team pages and leaderboards

- Event registration and ticketing

- Crowdfunding campaigns

- Recurring giving with retention tools

- Built-in CRM with segmentation

- Salesforce and Blackbaud integrations

- Advanced analytics and reporting

- A/B testing

- Multi-campaign management

Standout Strength

Enterprise-scale multi-channel fundraising that basic tools cannot approach. For organizations where We Did It's limitations actively constrain revenue growth, Classy provides professional onboarding and infrastructure for serious fundraising operations.

Best For

Mid-to-large nonprofits that have completely outgrown basic campaign tools. The enterprise upgrade when fundraising scale demands professional infrastructure.

Pricing Overview

- Custom pricing starting at $300+ per month

- Per-transaction platform fees

- Demo required

Limitations

- Dramatic cost increase from We Did It.

- Complex setup and learning curve.

- GoFundMe acquisition creates uncertainty.

Quick Comparison Insight

Enterprise infrastructure for organizations outgrowing campaign tools entirely. The professional upgrade when scale demands more.

7. GiveWP

Overview

GiveWP provides the WordPress-native path from We Did It. The free core plugin handles donation forms, recurring giving, and donor management within WordPress. For organizations already on WordPress, GiveWP provides comparable basic functionality with deeper customization and no platform fees.

Core Capabilities

- WordPress-native donation forms with template customization

- Recurring giving management

- Support for Stripe, PayPal, and additional gateways

- P2P fundraising through add-ons

- Donor management within WordPress

- Form builder with goals and fund designation

- Fee recovery option

- Reporting within WordPress admin

- CRM and email integrations via add-ons

- Full WordPress customization control

Standout Strength

Free core plugin with no platform fees. For WordPress organizations, GiveWP eliminates We Did It's 5% platform fee while providing deeper customization and integration within the WordPress ecosystem.

Best For

WordPress-committed organizations seeking zero platform fees with deeper website integration. Teams with technical capability for WordPress platform administration.

Pricing Overview

- Free core plugin

- Plus at approximately $349 per year

- Pro at approximately $499 per year

- WordPress hosting costs additional

Limitations

- WordPress lock-in.

- Self-hosted maintenance.

- Add-on costs for advanced features.

Quick Comparison Insight

Free WordPress-native alternative eliminating We Did It's platform fees. Requires WordPress but delivers better customization.

8. Fundraise Up

Overview

Fundraise Up provides AI-driven donation optimization for organizations seeking maximum revenue from online giving. The machine learning engine dynamically optimizes donation experiences to increase conversion rates and gift sizes. The technology-forward approach serves organizations ready to invest in revenue optimization.

Core Capabilities

- AI-optimized donation checkout

- Embeddable widgets and forms

- Recurring donation optimization

- Comprehensive payment support including crypto and DAF

- Built-in CRM with engagement scoring

- P2P and campaign pages

- Native Salesforce, Blackbaud, and Bloomerang integrations

- Multi-language and multi-currency support

- Built-in A/B testing

- Advanced analytics with conversion tracking

Standout Strength

AI optimization produces revenue lifts that basic campaign tools cannot deliver. For organizations with significant web traffic, the technology generates returns that justify premium pricing over We Did It's simpler approach. Organizations investing in engagement strategies across their digital presence see compounding benefits.

Best For

Mid-to-large nonprofits with substantial web traffic where AI optimization generates meaningful revenue increases. The premium upgrade when growth demands technology-driven fundraising.

Pricing Overview

- Free tier with approximately 5% platform fee

- Growth plan at approximately 2 to 3%

- Enterprise with custom pricing

- Transaction-based model

Limitations

- Premium pricing at higher tiers.

- Less effective for low-traffic organizations.

- Complex for small teams.

Quick Comparison Insight

AI-driven premium upgrade from basic campaign tools. The revenue optimization can generate returns exceeding We Did It's simpler model.

9. OneCause

Overview

OneCause specializes in event-based fundraising with mobile bidding, auctions, and live-event tools. For organizations expanding into galas and auction fundraising, OneCause provides event capabilities that We Did It and most online-only platforms do not offer.

Core Capabilities

- Mobile bidding for auctions

- Event registration with table management

- Online donation pages

- P2P campaigns

- Text-to-give

- Real-time event dashboards

- Auction management with item cataloging

- Donor management

- Post-event reporting and evaluation

- CRM integrations

Standout Strength

Event fundraising depth with mobile bidding and auction management. Addresses the in-person fundraising channel that We Did It's online-only approach completely ignores.

Best For

Nonprofits expanding into galas, auctions, and live events. Organizations partnering with elearning programs for charities while also running significant event-based fundraising programs.

Pricing Overview

- Custom pricing, $3,000 to $10,000+ per year

- Per-event pricing possible

- Demo required

Limitations

- Primarily event-focused.

- Expensive relative to simple campaign tools.

- Online donation features are secondary.

Quick Comparison Insight

Event tools We Did It does not offer. Essential when galas and auctions become significant revenue channels.

10. Donately

Overview

Donately provides lightweight, developer-friendly donation forms with API access and CSS customization. For technically capable teams wanting full control over the donation experience, Donately offers clean embeddable forms with developer tools that We Did It's limited customization cannot match.

Core Capabilities

- Embeddable donation forms via JavaScript

- Recurring donations

- Campaign pages with progress bars

- P2P fundraising pages

- Developer-friendly REST API

- Salesforce and Mailchimp integrations

- Donor management with data export

- Custom CSS styling

- Fee recovery option

- Multi-currency via Stripe

Standout Strength

Developer-friendly flexibility with API and CSS access. For teams wanting pixel-perfect branded donation experiences, Donately provides technical control that We Did It's constrained templates cannot match.

Best For

Developer-led teams needing technical control over the donation experience. Organizations valuing customization and API access over simplicity.

Pricing Overview

- Free plan (approximately 3% platform fee)

- Standard at $59 to $99 per month

- Premium at $149 to $199 per month

- Stripe as primary processor

Limitations

- Stripe-only processing.

- Smaller feature set than broader platforms.

- Free plan carries platform fees similar to We Did It.

Quick Comparison Insight

Developer flexibility versus We Did It's simplicity. More technical control for teams that need branded experiences.

How to Choose the Right Alternative

If cost savings matter most: Givebutter (zero platform fees), GiveLively (free for 501(c)(3) organizations), or GiveWP (free WordPress plugin).

If recurring giving is the priority: Donorbox provides the strongest monthly donor retention infrastructure.

If donor discovery matters: MightyCause offers a nonprofit directory for organic audience building.

If P2P campaigns drive revenue: CauseVox delivers dedicated campaign management with coaching and gamification.

If enterprise scale is needed: Classy and Fundraise Up serve organizations outgrowing basic tools.

If events matter: OneCause provides auction and event tools.

If developer control matters: Donately offers API access and CSS customization.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does We Did It charge?

We Did It operates on a transaction-based model with no monthly subscription. The platform charges approximately 5% of donations raised on top of standard credit card processing fees (roughly 2.9% plus $0.30 per transaction). The total effective cost per donation reaches approximately 7 to 8%.

Is We Did It good for large nonprofits?

We Did It is designed for small organizations and grassroots fundraising. The 5% platform fee becomes expensive at scale, and the limited feature set (no CRM, no email tools, no event management) constrains larger operations. Organizations raising over $100,000 annually typically find subscription-based alternatives more cost-effective.

What is the cheapest We Did It alternative?

Givebutter charges zero platform fees with broader features. GiveLively is completely free for 501(c)(3) organizations. GiveWP's free core plugin costs nothing beyond WordPress hosting. All three eliminate We Did It's 5% platform fee entirely.

Can I migrate donor data from We Did It?

Most We Did It donor data can be exported via CSV and imported into alternative platforms. Contact your new platform's support team to confirm import compatibility. Plan migrations during low-volume periods to minimize disruption.

Does We Did It have a CRM?

We Did It provides basic donor data capture and export but does not include a built-in CRM. Donor segmentation, communication tools, engagement tracking, and stewardship workflows require external tools. Alternatives like Givebutter and CauseVox include built-in CRM functionality.