10 Best Tithe.ly Alternatives for Church Giving

Why Look for a Tithe.ly Alternative?

Tithe.ly positioned itself as the budget-friendly, all-in-one church technology platform, bundling giving, church apps, websites, ChMS, and streaming under one roof. The breadth appealed to churches wanting a single vendor at an affordable price. But the jack-of-all-trades approach creates limitations that push churches toward specialized alternatives.

Individual features lack depth. Tithe.ly covers many areas but masters none. The ChMS is less capable than Planning Center. The church app is less polished than Subsplash. The giving analytics are less advanced than Pushpay. Churches that initially valued the bundled convenience eventually find that each component falls short of what dedicated platforms deliver.

Customer support inconsistency. Reviews frequently cite slow response times and difficulty reaching human support, particularly on the free tier. When giving is involved, support delays directly affect church revenue. Churches processing significant donation volume need reliable, responsive support that Tithe.ly does not consistently provide.

Transaction fees are not competitive. Tithe.ly's standard 2.9% plus $0.30 per transaction is industry average but not competitive against platforms offering lower rates. Planning Center Giving charges 2.15% plus $0.30 for cards and 0.80% for ACH. For churches processing $500,000 or more annually, the fee difference amounts to thousands of dollars in savings.

Elvanto acquisition uncertainty. Tithe.ly acquired Elvanto, creating product overlap between Tithe.ly ChMS and Elvanto. Churches question which platform represents the long-term investment and whether the ChMS component will receive focused development or remain a secondary feature to the giving platform.

Limited advanced donor analytics. Tithe.ly provides basic giving reports but lacks the donor development tools, lapsed donor identification, and generosity benchmarking that platforms like Pushpay deliver. Churches wanting to grow their giving culture need deeper insights than Tithe.ly's dashboards provide.

If your church needs lower transaction fees, deeper giving analytics, more polished individual tools, or reliable support, these alternatives address those specific gaps.

What to Consider When Switching from Tithe.ly

Tithe.ly's bundled approach means switching may affect multiple operational areas beyond giving.

Recurring donor transition. Export recurring donor schedules before switching. Coordinate with your new platform to minimize the gap between deactivating Tithe.ly giving and activating the replacement. Communicate the change to recurring donors with clear instructions. A structured onboarding process reduces donor confusion during the transition.

Bundled service replacement. If you use Tithe.ly's ChMS, church app, or website alongside giving, switching the giving platform may trigger a broader technology evaluation. Decide whether to replace just giving or the entire Tithe.ly stack.

Transaction fee comparison. Compare total processing costs, not just advertised rates. Factor in monthly subscription fees, per-transaction charges, ACH versus card rates, and whether your church uses donor-covers-fees options. Model costs at your actual giving volume for accurate comparison.

Donor data portability. Export complete giving history, donor records, and fund designations. Most platforms accept CSV imports, but verify field mapping before committing to migration. Use an evaluation checklist to ensure all data transfers correctly.

Text-to-give number portability. If your church promotes a text-to-give number, confirm whether you can port that number to your new platform or will need to communicate a new one to your congregation.

10 Best Tithe.ly Alternatives

These platforms serve churches that need lower fees, deeper analytics, more polished experiences, or specialized giving capabilities beyond Tithe.ly's bundled approach.

Planning Center Giving (Church Center)

Overview

Planning Center Giving offers the lowest transaction fees in the church giving market combined with the cleanest giving experience. The module integrates smoothly with Planning Center's stack, connecting giving data to member records, groups, and services. For churches already using any Planning Center module, adding Giving is the most natural and cost-effective choice.

The Church Center app gives members a clean, direct path to manage recurring gifts, view giving history, and access tax statements. The interface is straightforward enough that donors need no training, and the design quality is comparable to mainstream consumer apps.

Core Capabilities

- Online giving with clean, branded donation forms

- Church Center app with built-in giving experience

- Recurring giving with flexible scheduling options

- Fund management with visibility controls

- Batch entry for cash and check donations

- ACH and card processing at industry-low rates

- Donor management linked to Planning Center People

- Automated year-end giving statements

- Deep integration with all Planning Center modules

- Embeddable giving forms for church websites

Standout Strength

Lowest transaction fees in the church giving market. Planning Center charges 2.15% plus $0.30 for cards and 0.80% plus $0.05 for ACH, saving churches thousands annually compared to Tithe.ly's 2.9% plus $0.30 standard rate.

Best For

Churches already using any Planning Center module, and cost-conscious churches (100 to 10,000+ members) that want the lowest possible processing fees with clean design.

Pricing Overview

- Giving module subscription is free

- Card processing: 2.15% plus $0.30 per transaction

- ACH processing: 0.80% plus $0.05 per transaction

- No contracts, month-to-month billing

- Other Planning Center modules priced separately

Limitations

- No text-to-give functionality.

- Requires Planning Center stack for full value.

- No standalone custom branded church app (shared Church Center app).

Quick Comparison Insight

Lower transaction fees than Tithe.ly with cleaner design, but no text-to-give and best used within the Planning Center stack.

Pushpay

Overview

Pushpay occupies the high end of church giving platforms, built around a specific problem: converting first-time donors into recurring givers. Its onboarding flow is designed to increase recurring commitment rates at a level that basic giving tools rarely approach. For mid-size to large churches treating giving growth as a strategic priority, the donor development features and analytics are the main justification for its pricing premium.

The custom branded church app with integrated giving, media, groups, and engagement tools provides a more polished mobile experience than Tithe.ly's app builder delivers.

Core Capabilities

- Mobile-first giving with optimized conversion flows

- Custom branded church app with full engagement features

- Recurring giving management with retention optimization

- Text-to-give via SMS keywords

- Donor development tools with lapsed donor identification

- Generosity benchmarking and giving analytics

- In-venue giving kiosks

- Push notifications for engagement campaigns

- Batch processing with detailed financial reporting

- CCB ChMS integration for unified member data

Standout Strength

Highest recurring giving adoption rates in the industry. Pushpay's donor conversion engineering produces 60 to 80%+ recurring giving rates versus the industry average of approximately 30%. For large churches, this translates to hundreds of thousands in additional annual revenue.

Best For

Mid-size to large churches (500 to 10,000+ members) that prioritize maximizing digital giving revenue and are willing to invest premium pricing for measurable ROI.

Pricing Overview

- Custom contract-based pricing starting approximately $199 to $799+ per month

- Transaction fees typically 1.5% to 2.5% depending on contract

- Multi-year contracts (2 to 3 years) are standard

- No free tier or trial

Limitations

- Significantly more expensive than Tithe.ly.

- Multi-year contracts create long-term commitment risk.

- Advanced features only pay for themselves at scale (500+ members).

Quick Comparison Insight

Premium giving tools that dramatically outperform Tithe.ly in donor conversion and analytics, at substantially higher cost with longer commitment.

Subsplash Giving

Overview

Subsplash delivers a high-quality custom church app with giving built directly into the branded mobile experience. For churches that tried an app builder and found it fell short on design and stability, Subsplash offers an app-store-quality mobile presence with integrated giving, media hosting, and community engagement tools.

The giving module performs comparably to dedicated platforms while the app quality exceeds what both Tithe.ly and Pushpay provide for the same price tier.

Core Capabilities

- Custom branded church app (iOS and Android) with giving built in

- Online giving with custom branded donation pages

- Text-to-give via SMS keywords

- Recurring giving with flexible scheduling

- In-app giving with smooth donor experience

- Media hosting for sermons and video content

- Push notifications for engagement and giving campaigns

- Giving kiosk support for in-venue donations

- Donor management with giving analytics

- Website integration with embeddable giving widgets

Standout Strength

High-quality custom church apps with integrated giving. Subsplash apps are widely regarded as among the best-designed in the category, offering Pushpay-level production quality at more accessible pricing while outperforming lighter app-builder tools across every interface dimension.

Best For

Mid-size to large churches (300 to 5,000+ members) that want a premium branded mobile app with giving, media, and engagement integrated into one polished experience.

Pricing Overview

- Giving-only plans available at lower cost

- App plus giving bundles approximately $99 to $399+ per month

- Transaction fees: 2.3% to 2.9% plus $0.30 for cards

- ACH approximately 1% or lower

- Typically annual contracts for app plans

Limitations

- Premium pricing exceeds Tithe.ly significantly.

- Giving is strongest when bundled with the app product.

- Less cost-effective for churches that only need giving without an app.

Quick Comparison Insight

Stronger app quality and a more cohesive giving experience, at higher cost, best for churches where a branded mobile presence is a core ministry tool.

Givelify

Overview

Givelify provides the simplest mobile giving experience in the market through a donor-facing app marketplace. Unlike Tithe.ly's church-centric model, Givelify has a consumer-facing app where donors download the app, search for their church, and give with minimal friction. This two-sided marketplace creates a discovery channel that no other platform offers.

The zero-monthly-fee model matches Tithe.ly's free tier in cost structure while providing a more focused giving experience without the complexity of bundled features.

Core Capabilities

- Donor-facing mobile app with church search and discovery

- Online giving through web portal

- Recurring giving with automated scheduling

- Virtual giving envelopes for designated funds

- Real-time giving dashboard for church administrators

- Donor giving history and personal tax receipts

- QuickBooks integration for accounting

- Near-instant setup with minimal configuration

- Multi-faith support (churches, mosques, synagogues)

- Next-business-day deposit processing

Standout Strength

The donor-facing app marketplace where new donors discover churches. Givelify is the only giving platform with a consumer-grade discovery feature, providing a Venmo-like simplicity that Tithe.ly's church-centric giving forms cannot match for donor convenience.

Best For

Small to mid-size churches (any denomination) that prioritize the simplest possible donor experience, diverse and multicultural congregations, and churches wanting zero monthly fees.

Pricing Overview

- Zero monthly subscription fee

- Card transaction fees: 2.9% plus $0.30

- ACH fees: approximately 1% plus $0.30

- No contracts, cancel anytime

- Donor-covers-fees option available

Limitations

- No church management, app builder, or website features.

- Church branding takes a back seat to the Givelify brand.

- Limited customization of the giving experience.

Quick Comparison Insight

Simpler donor experience than Tithe.ly with a unique marketplace model, but no bundled features and less church branding control.

EasyTithe

Overview

EasyTithe delivers exactly what its name promises: easy online giving setup without complexity. The platform can be operational within 30 minutes, adding giving to any existing church website through embeddable widgets. For churches that only need giving without Tithe.ly's bundled ChMS, app, and website features, EasyTithe provides a focused solution without unnecessary complexity.

Now part of the Ministry Brands stack alongside Pushpay and ShelbyNext, EasyTithe offers native integration with Shelby and CCB for churches using those management platforms.

Core Capabilities

- Customizable online giving pages

- Mobile-optimized giving experience

- Text-to-give via SMS keywords

- Recurring giving with automated scheduling

- In-lobby giving kiosk support

- Embeddable giving widget for existing websites

- Donor management with giving statements

- Ministry Brands stack integration

- Batch processing for cash and check donations

- Year-end tax statement generation

Standout Strength

Fastest setup in the church giving market. EasyTithe adds functional online giving to any church website in under 30 minutes with zero learning curve, making it the lowest-friction entry point for churches new to digital giving.

Best For

Small to mid-size churches (under 500 members) that want simple online giving without additional features, especially those already using Ministry Brands products.

Pricing Overview

- Basic plans starting at approximately $0 to $49 per month

- Standard plans approximately $59 to $99 per month with text-to-give

- Card transaction fees: 2.9% plus $0.30

- ACH at reduced rates (approximately 1%)

- Donor-covers-fees option available

Limitations

- Giving-only platform with no ChMS, app, or website features.

- Ministry Brands consolidation creates product roadmap uncertainty.

- Reporting and analytics are basic compared to advanced platforms.

Quick Comparison Insight

Simpler and more focused than Tithe.ly for giving-only needs, but none of the bundled stack features that define Tithe.ly's value proposition.

Vanco Giving

Overview

Vanco has processed church donations since the early 2000s and built its reputation on electronic fund transfer reliability. For congregations where bank transfer giving dominates and finance teams are focused on minimizing processing costs, Vanco's ACH rates are among the lowest available, typically around 0.75% plus $0.25, compared to the roughly 1% ACH rate that most alternatives charge.

Traditional and mainline denominations, including Catholic, Lutheran, Methodist, and Presbyterian churches, have long favored Vanco for its payment processing reliability and low bank transfer costs.

Core Capabilities

- Online giving pages with web-based donation forms

- Mobile giving through Vanco Mobile Faith app

- Text-to-give via SMS keywords

- Recurring giving with flexible automated schedules

- ACH and electronic fund transfer processing (core strength)

- In-venue giving kiosks and card terminals

- Batch processing for cash and check deposits

- GivePlus branded giving stack

- Detailed financial reporting and fund tracking

- Year-end giving statements

Standout Strength

Lowest ACH processing fees in the church giving market. Vanco charges approximately 0.75% plus $0.25 for bank transfers, saving churches with high ACH volume thousands annually compared to Tithe.ly's approximately 1% ACH rate.

Best For

Mid-size to large churches with high ACH giving volume, mainline and traditional denominations, and finance teams prioritizing the lowest possible transaction costs.

Pricing Overview

- Monthly fees: approximately $0 to $50 depending on plan

- Card processing: 2.75% plus $0.45 per transaction

- ACH processing: approximately 0.75% plus $0.25 (very competitive)

- Some plans have annual contracts

- Volume-based rate reductions available

Limitations

- Admin interface and donor experience feel dated compared to Tithe.ly.

- Card processing fees are actually higher than most competitors.

- Complex product lineup creates confusion about which plan to choose.

Quick Comparison Insight

Lower ACH fees than Tithe.ly for bank-transfer-heavy churches, but higher card fees and a dated user experience.

Donorbox

Overview

Donorbox provides embeddable donation forms that work for both churches and nonprofits, and can be placed on any website with minimal technical setup. For churches that want giving functionality without being locked into a dedicated church platform, Donorbox offers broader flexibility, including peer-to-peer fundraising and crowdfunding that most church-specific tools do not support.

The platform processes donations for organizations across faith and nonprofit sectors, and its form design reflects fundraising patterns drawn from a wider nonprofit base rather than church-specific workflows alone.

Core Capabilities

- Embeddable donation forms with custom branding

- Recurring giving with flexible scheduling

- Peer-to-peer fundraising campaigns

- Crowdfunding pages for special projects

- Text-to-give functionality

- Multiple payment processor options (Stripe, PayPal)

- Donor management with CRM features

- Customizable giving pages and pop-up forms

- Multi-currency and international giving support

- Automated tax receipts and giving statements

Standout Strength

Flexible donation forms with peer-to-peer and crowdfunding capabilities that church-specific platforms do not provide. Donorbox gives churches fundraising tools beyond weekly tithing, supporting building campaigns, mission trips, and community projects.

Best For

Churches (any size) that need flexible fundraising beyond standard tithing, especially those running capital campaigns, mission projects, or community fundraising alongside regular giving.

Pricing Overview

- Free plan for basic features (up to $1,000 per month in donations)

- Standard plan starting at approximately $45 per month

- Pro plan with advanced features at higher tiers

- Transaction fees: payment processor fees apply (Stripe or PayPal rates)

- No long-term contracts

Limitations

- Not designed specifically for church giving workflows.

- No ChMS, church app, or worship planning features.

- Lacks church-specific features like fund envelope management.

Quick Comparison Insight

More flexible fundraising than Tithe.ly with peer-to-peer and crowdfunding, but less church-specific in design and terminology.

Stripe (for Churches)

Overview

Stripe is the payment infrastructure layer that many church giving platforms, including Tithe.ly, use under the hood. Going directly to Stripe removes the intermediary markup and gives churches access to base processing rates. For congregations with technical capacity, or those using website builders that already integrate Stripe natively, this approach can cut processing costs below what any dedicated giving platform offers.

This approach requires more training and technical capability than using a purpose-built giving platform, but the cost savings scale directly with giving volume.

Core Capabilities

- Payment processing for cards and ACH transfers

- Recurring payment scheduling

- Custom donation forms through Stripe Elements

- Invoicing for pledge management

- Detailed financial reporting and analytics

- Webhook integrations for automated workflows

- Multi-currency international payment support

- PCI-compliant payment infrastructure

- Developer API for custom integrations

- Stripe Connect for marketplace-style giving

Standout Strength

Lowest base transaction rates without giving platform markup. Stripe charges 2.9% plus $0.30 for cards and 0.80% for ACH, but churches using Stripe Billing or negotiated rates can achieve lower costs than any church-specific platform, particularly at high volume.

Best For

Technically capable churches with development resources or website platforms that integrate Stripe natively, especially high-volume churches wanting to minimize processing costs.

Pricing Overview

- No monthly subscription fee

- Standard card processing: 2.9% plus $0.30

- ACH processing: 0.80% with $5 cap per transaction

- Volume discounts available for large processors

- Custom enterprise pricing for high-volume organizations

Limitations

- No church-specific features, donor management, or giving statements.

- Requires technical implementation or third-party form builder.

- No text-to-give, church app, or branded giving experience.

Quick Comparison Insight

Lower base costs than Tithe.ly by removing the platform markup, but requires technical capability and provides no church-specific functionality.

PayPal (for Churches)

Overview

PayPal brings name recognition and donor trust that dedicated church platforms cannot replicate. Most potential donors already have an account, which removes the step of creating a new giving profile entirely. For churches where reducing adoption friction is the primary concern, PayPal's ubiquity gives it a practical advantage that specialized branding cannot substitute.

PayPal's nonprofit and religious organization programs offer reduced processing rates and donation-specific features that general commercial accounts do not include.

Core Capabilities

- Donation buttons and embeddable giving forms

- PayPal Checkout with familiar donor experience

- Recurring donation scheduling

- PayPal.me links for simple sharing

- Venmo integration for younger donors

- QR code giving for in-service donations

- Donor email receipts and records

- Multi-currency international payment support

- Mobile and desktop payment processing

- Integration with virtually any website platform

Standout Strength

Universal donor familiarity that eliminates adoption friction. PayPal's brand recognition means donors trust the payment process immediately, and most already have accounts, removing the barrier that church-specific platforms create when asking donors to create new giving accounts.

Best For

Churches of any size that prioritize donor convenience and familiarity, international churches with donors in multiple countries, and churches wanting giving options alongside a primary giving platform.

Pricing Overview

- No monthly subscription for basic donation features

- Standard processing: 2.89% plus $0.49 per transaction

- Nonprofit reduced rates: 1.99% plus $0.49 (for qualified organizations)

- PayPal Giving Fund: 0% fees for registered charities (verify eligibility)

- No contracts required

Limitations

- No church-specific donor management or giving statements.

- Lacks recurring giving optimization and donor development tools.

- Fee structure is less transparent than dedicated giving platforms.

Quick Comparison Insight

Unmatched donor familiarity compared to Tithe.ly, with potential for lower nonprofit rates, but no church-specific features or giving statements.

Breeze ChMS (Giving)

Overview

Breeze includes built-in giving alongside its church management platform, providing an integrated experience where donor data connects directly to member records, attendance, and group involvement. For churches that want giving and management in one simple platform without Tithe.ly's stack complexity, Breeze delivers both through the most user-friendly interface in church management.

The giving module handles online donations, text-to-give, recurring gifts, and contribution tracking with the same zero-training philosophy that defines Breeze's approach to church management.

Core Capabilities

- Online giving with branded donation forms

- Text-to-give functionality

- Recurring donations with automated scheduling

- Contribution tracking with fund management

- Batch entry for cash and check donations

- Donor statements and year-end tax receipts

- Giving reports and analytics dashboards

- Integrated with Breeze member database

- Mobile-responsive giving experience

- Donor-covers-fees option

Standout Strength

Giving integrated with the simplest church management platform on the market. Breeze connects donor data to member records without the complexity that Tithe.ly's broader stack creates, providing management plus giving at a predictable flat rate.

Best For

Small to mid-size churches (50 to 500 members) that want giving and basic church management in one simple, affordable platform without enterprise features.

Pricing Overview

- Flat rate of approximately $72 to $100 per month (includes management and giving)

- Processing fees: standard card rates apply

- All features included with no module charges

- No long-term contracts

- Unlimited users and records

Limitations

- Giving features are less specialized than dedicated platforms.

- No custom church app or website builder.

- Giving analytics are basic compared to Pushpay or Subsplash.

Quick Comparison Insight

Simpler integration of giving plus management than Tithe.ly, at a comparable price, but without app builder, website, or media features.

Where Teachfloor Fits

The tools above handle Tithe.ly. To actually build, deliver, and manage the courses or training programs around them, you need a learning platform. Teachfloor is a flexible course and training platform: run programs self-paced, social, live, or in cohorts, with built-in community, peer review, AI course creation, certificates, and white-label branding on your own domain. It pairs well with the tools on this list, hosting and structuring the learning experience around them.

If you are choosing a home for your courses rather than a single-purpose tool, Teachfloor is worth a look. It starts at $89 per month with a 14-day free trial.

How to Choose the Right Tithe.ly Alternative

Match your selection to the specific limitation driving the change.

If transaction fees are the priority, Planning Center Giving offers the lowest rates in the market (2.15% cards, 0.80% ACH). Vanco provides the lowest ACH rates for bank-transfer-heavy churches. For churches managing this evaluation, principles from eLearning for charities can help structure the decision process.

If giving growth and analytics matter, Pushpay provides the deepest donor development tools and highest recurring giving conversion rates.

If a branded mobile app is essential, Subsplash delivers the most polished custom church app with giving built in.

If simplicity is the goal, Givelify provides zero-friction mobile giving. EasyTithe adds online giving to any website in minutes. Breeze bundles simple giving with management.

If you need fundraising beyond tithing, Donorbox offers peer-to-peer campaigns and crowdfunding that church-specific platforms lack.

If donor familiarity matters, PayPal provides universal brand recognition that eliminates giving account creation friction.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the cheapest Tithe.ly alternative?

Planning Center Giving has no monthly subscription and the lowest processing fees (2.15% plus $0.30 for cards, 0.80% for ACH). Givelify also has no monthly fee at standard processing rates. Both are cheaper than Tithe.ly's free tier when comparing total processing costs on equivalent giving volume.

Can I use Tithe.ly's ChMS alternatives alongside a different giving platform?

Yes. Most church management platforms integrate with or can coexist alongside separate giving tools. Planning Center has its own native giving. Breeze includes built-in giving. Other ChMS platforms like CCB integrate with Pushpay. You can mix specialized tools to get the best of each category.

Which Tithe.ly alternative has the best mobile giving experience?

Pushpay and Subsplash provide the most polished mobile giving through custom branded apps. Givelify offers the simplest donor-facing mobile experience through its marketplace app. Planning Center's Church Center app provides clean mobile giving within a broader church engagement experience.

Is it worth paying more for Pushpay over free alternatives?

For churches processing over $500,000 annually, Pushpay's higher recurring giving conversion rates can generate enough additional revenue to offset its premium pricing. For churches under $200,000 in annual giving, free or low-cost alternatives like Planning Center Giving provide better cost efficiency.