10 Best Pushpay Alternatives for Church Giving

Why Look for a Pushpay Alternative?

Pushpay established itself as the premium church giving platform, trusted by megachurches for its ability to convert first-time donors into recurring givers. The donor development tools, custom branded apps, and engagement analytics deliver genuine ROI for large churches. But Pushpay's premium positioning creates barriers that push many churches toward alternatives.

Pricing is prohibitively high. Pushpay's contract-based pricing, starting at approximately $199 per month and reaching $799 or more for larger churches, places it beyond the budget of most small and mid-size congregations. The total annual cost of $3,000 to $10,000+ for a giving platform alone feels disproportionate when free and low-cost alternatives exist.

Multi-year contracts create risk. Pushpay typically requires two to three year commitments. Churches that outgrow the platform, experience budget constraints, or find the ROI insufficient are locked into payments for years. This contract structure represents financial risk that month-to-month alternatives eliminate.

Ownership uncertainty. Pushpay merged with Church Community Builder, then was acquired by Pegasus (Ministry Brands parent). The consolidation into the largest church technology conglomerate raises questions about product direction, price increases, and support quality. Multiple ownership changes in rapid succession create uncertainty that affects long-term platform confidence.

Overkill for smaller churches. Pushpay's advanced donor analytics, generosity benchmarking, and engagement optimization tools deliver ROI only at scale. Churches under 300 members rarely see enough giving volume to justify the premium pricing. The sophisticated features go underutilized while the cost remains fixed.

No free tier or trial. Unlike most competitors that offer free plans or trials, Pushpay requires a sales conversation and contract commitment before any evaluation. Churches cannot test the platform with their congregation before making a multi-year financial commitment.

If your church needs more affordable giving, flexible contracts, or appropriately scaled tools, these alternatives provide comparable or superior value at significantly lower cost.

What to Consider When Switching from Pushpay

Pushpay's premium features set a high baseline for comparison. Plan the transition to preserve giving continuity.

Recurring giving migration. Pushpay's strength is recurring donor conversion. Transitioning these donors to a new platform requires careful communication. Export recurring donor schedules and coordinate with your replacement to minimize disruption. A structured onboarding process ensures donors transition their recurring gifts smoothly.

Contract exit timing. Review your Pushpay contract for renewal dates, cancellation windows, and early termination fees. Begin evaluating alternatives well before your contract end date to avoid automatic renewal.

App transition. If your church uses Pushpay's custom branded app, your congregation will need to download a new app from your replacement platform. Communicate the change clearly and provide transition support to avoid losing mobile engagement.

Giving analytics baseline. Before leaving Pushpay, export your giving analytics data, including recurring rates, average gift sizes, donor retention metrics, and giving trends. This baseline helps you measure whether your replacement platform maintains or improves giving performance. Use an evaluation checklist to compare platforms against these metrics.

Processing rate comparison. Compare total costs including subscription fees and transaction rates at your actual giving volume. A platform with higher per-transaction rates but no monthly fee may cost less overall than Pushpay depending on your church's giving patterns.

10 Best Pushpay Alternatives

These platforms serve churches that need effective giving tools at lower cost, with flexible terms, or at a scale appropriate to their size.

Planning Center Giving (Church Center)

Overview

Planning Center Giving provides the lowest transaction fees in the church giving market with no monthly subscription for the giving module itself. The platform integrates smoothly with Planning Center's broader stack, connecting giving data to member records, groups, services, and events. For churches using any Planning Center module, adding Giving is the most cost-effective alternative to Pushpay.

The Church Center app delivers a clean, member-facing giving experience that, while not as feature-rich as Pushpay's custom app, provides a polished mobile giving interface without the premium pricing.

Core Capabilities

- Online giving with branded donation forms

- Church Center app with integrated giving experience

- Recurring giving with flexible scheduling

- Fund management with visibility controls

- Batch entry for cash and check donations

- ACH and card processing at the lowest market rates

- Donor management linked to Planning Center People

- Automated year-end giving statements

- Deep integration with Planning Center modules

- Embeddable giving forms for church websites

Standout Strength

Lowest transaction fees in church giving with no monthly subscription. Planning Center charges 2.15% plus $0.30 for cards and 0.80% plus $0.05 for ACH, saving churches processing $500,000 annually approximately $3,750 compared to industry-average rates.

Best For

Churches (100 to 10,000+ members) already using Planning Center or prioritizing the lowest possible processing fees with clean design and no contracts.

Pricing Overview

- Giving module: free (no monthly subscription)

- Card processing: 2.15% plus $0.30 per transaction

- ACH processing: 0.80% plus $0.05 per transaction

- No contracts, month-to-month billing

- Other Planning Center modules priced separately

Limitations

- No text-to-give functionality.

- No custom branded church app (shared Church Center app).

- Lacks Pushpay's advanced donor development tools and generosity benchmarks.

Quick Comparison Insight

Dramatically lower total cost than Pushpay with clean design and no contracts, but without advanced donor analytics or text-to-give.

Subsplash Giving

Overview

Subsplash delivers the closest experience to Pushpay's premium custom church app with giving built in, at more accessible pricing. The platform is widely regarded as having the most polished custom church apps available, with giving, media, groups, and engagement features integrated into a branded mobile experience that matches Pushpay's quality.

For churches that value Pushpay's app quality but find the pricing excessive, Subsplash provides comparable mobile presence without multi-year commitment requirements at Pushpay's price tier.

Core Capabilities

- Custom branded church app (iOS and Android) with integrated giving

- Online giving with custom branded donation pages

- Text-to-give via SMS keywords

- Recurring giving with flexible scheduling

- In-app giving with smooth donor experience

- Media hosting for sermons and video content

- Push notifications for community engagement campaigns

- Giving kiosk support for in-venue donations

- Donor management with giving analytics

- Website integration with embeddable widgets

Standout Strength

Pushpay-quality custom church apps at more accessible pricing. Subsplash delivers the branded mobile experience Pushpay provides without requiring the same premium investment, making high-quality church apps accessible to mid-size congregations.

Best For

Mid-size to large churches (300 to 5,000+ members) that want Pushpay-quality branded apps with giving at a more accessible price point.

Pricing Overview

- Giving-only plans at lower cost

- App plus giving bundles approximately $99 to $399+ per month

- Card transaction fees: 2.3% to 2.9% plus $0.30

- ACH approximately 1% or lower

- Typically annual contracts for app plans

Limitations

- Still premium pricing compared to budget alternatives.

- Giving analytics are less advanced than Pushpay's donor development tools.

- App focus means giving-only churches overpay for bundled features.

Quick Comparison Insight

Closest match to Pushpay's app quality at lower cost, but without the advanced donor conversion optimization that defines Pushpay.

Tithe.ly

Overview

Tithe.ly provides the broadest all-in-one church technology platform at budget pricing, bundling giving, church apps, websites, ChMS, and media streaming under one roof. For churches that Pushpay priced out of premium giving, Tithe.ly's free giving tier provides functional online donations without monthly subscription costs.

The breadth of bundled features means churches gain not just giving but an entire digital infrastructure, addressing multiple technology needs that Pushpay requires separate vendors to fulfill.

Core Capabilities

- Online giving with embeddable donation forms

- Mobile giving app (branded or Tithe.ly-branded)

- Text-to-give via SMS keywords

- Recurring giving with automated scheduling

- In-lobby giving kiosk mode

- Custom church app builder

- Church website builder with integrated giving

- Church management (ChMS) with people database

- Streaming and media tools

- Donor management with giving reports and statements

Standout Strength

Broadest all-in-one stack at budget pricing. Tithe.ly provides giving plus app plus website plus ChMS plus media at a total cost lower than Pushpay's giving-only subscription, making it the most value per dollar for budget-conscious churches.

Best For

Small to mid-size churches (50 to 500 members) wanting an affordable all-in-one platform that replaces Pushpay and multiple other vendors simultaneously.

Pricing Overview

- Free tier for giving only (transaction fees apply)

- Plus plans approximately $49 to $99 per month

- Pro plans approximately $149 to $199 per month for full suite

- Card transaction fees: 2.9% plus $0.30

- ACH at reduced rates (approximately 1%)

Limitations

- Individual features lack Pushpay's polish and depth.

- Customer support consistency is an ongoing concern.

- Transaction fees are higher than Planning Center Giving.

Quick Comparison Insight

More total features than Pushpay at significantly lower cost, but each individual feature is less polished than Pushpay's focused giving tools.

Givelify

Overview

Givelify provides the simplest mobile giving experience through a consumer-facing app marketplace. Donors download the Givelify app, search for their church, and give in seconds, no account creation from your church, no configuration, no onboarding steps. The setup burden that Pushpay places on church administrators disappears entirely.

The zero monthly fee model means churches pay nothing until donations are processed, providing a risk-free alternative to Pushpay's upfront financial commitment.

Core Capabilities

- Donor-facing mobile app with church search and discovery

- Online giving through web portal

- Recurring giving with automated scheduling

- Virtual giving envelopes for designated funds

- Real-time giving dashboard for administrators

- Donor giving history and personal tax receipts

- QuickBooks integration for accounting

- Near-instant setup with minimal configuration

- Multi-faith support across denominations

- Next-business-day deposit processing

Standout Strength

Consumer-grade simplicity with a unique donor marketplace. Givelify's donor-facing app provides the easiest giving experience available, with a discovery channel where new donors can find your church without any marketing from your side.

Best For

Small to mid-size churches that prioritize the simplest possible donor experience, diverse congregations, and churches wanting zero monthly fees with zero commitment.

Pricing Overview

- Zero monthly subscription fee

- Card transactions: 2.9% plus $0.30

- ACH: approximately 1% plus $0.30

- No contracts, cancel anytime

- Donor-covers-fees option available

Limitations

- No church management, app builder, or engagement features.

- Church branding is subordinate to the Givelify brand.

- No donor development tools or giving analytics at Pushpay's level.

Quick Comparison Insight

Zero-friction giving with no monthly cost versus Pushpay's premium approach. Dramatically simpler and cheaper, but without advanced donor optimization.

EasyTithe

Overview

EasyTithe delivers straightforward online giving that can be operational within 30 minutes. The platform focuses exclusively on giving without bundled features, providing a clean alternative for churches that find Pushpay's feature breadth unnecessary. As a Ministry Brands product alongside Pushpay, EasyTithe serves churches that want giving tools from the same stack at a lower price tier.

For churches that valued Pushpay's Ministry Brands stack but could not justify the premium pricing, EasyTithe provides a budget entry point within the same vendor family.

Core Capabilities

- Customizable online giving pages

- Mobile-optimized giving experience

- Text-to-give via SMS keywords

- Recurring giving with automated scheduling

- In-lobby giving kiosk support

- Embeddable giving widget for existing websites

- Donor management with giving statements

- Ministry Brands stack integration

- Batch processing for offline donations

- Year-end tax statement generation

Standout Strength

Fastest setup in church giving. EasyTithe adds online giving to any church website in under 30 minutes, providing the lowest-friction path from no digital giving to functional online donations.

Best For

Small to mid-size churches (under 500 members) wanting simple, focused giving at a fraction of Pushpay's cost, especially those using other Ministry Brands products.

Pricing Overview

- Basic plans starting at approximately $0 to $49 per month

- Standard plans approximately $59 to $99 with text-to-give

- Card transaction fees: 2.9% plus $0.30

- ACH at reduced rates

- Donor-covers-fees option available

Limitations

- Giving-only platform with no app, management, or engagement.

- Ministry Brands consolidation creates product roadmap questions.

- Basic reporting compared to Pushpay's analytics.

Quick Comparison Insight

Simple giving at Pushpay's fraction of cost within the same vendor stack, but without any of Pushpay's advanced donor tools.

Vanco Giving

Overview

Vanco provides the lowest ACH processing fees in church giving, making it the optimal choice for churches where bank transfer donations dominate. Traditional and mainline denominations with established ACH giving programs save thousands annually compared to both Pushpay's bundled processing and Tithe.ly's standard rates.

Finance teams and church treasurers who prioritize minimizing processing costs over donor engagement features find Vanco's fee structure delivers the highest return on giving platform investment.

Core Capabilities

- Online giving with web-based donation pages

- Mobile giving through Vanco Mobile Faith app

- Text-to-give via SMS keywords

- Recurring giving with flexible scheduling

- ACH and electronic fund transfer processing (core strength)

- In-venue giving kiosks and card terminals

- Batch processing for cash and check deposits

- GivePlus branded giving stack

- Detailed financial reporting and fund tracking

- Year-end giving statements

Standout Strength

Lowest ACH processing fees in the church giving market. Vanco charges approximately 0.75% plus $0.25 for bank transfers, saving ACH-heavy churches thousands compared to Pushpay's bundled processing rates.

Best For

Mid-size to large churches with high ACH giving volume, mainline denominations, and finance teams prioritizing minimal transaction fees over advanced donor engagement features.

Pricing Overview

- Monthly fees: approximately $0 to $50 depending on plan

- Card processing: 2.75% plus $0.45 per transaction

- ACH processing: approximately 0.75% plus $0.25

- Volume-based rate reductions available

- Some plans have annual contracts

Limitations

- User interface feels dated compared to Pushpay.

- Card processing fees are higher than most competitors.

- No custom app, engagement tools, or donor development features.

Quick Comparison Insight

Lowest ACH fees versus Pushpay's premium processing costs, but dated interface and no donor engagement tools.

Donorbox

Overview

Donorbox provides flexible donation tools that extend beyond standard church tithing into peer-to-peer fundraising, crowdfunding, and campaign-based giving. For churches that need fundraising capabilities alongside regular weekly giving, Donorbox offers tools that Pushpay and most church-specific platforms do not provide.

The platform serves both churches and nonprofits, drawing on fundraising patterns across sectors to support conversion across recurring gifts, campaign contributions, and one-time donations.

Core Capabilities

- Embeddable donation forms with custom branding

- Recurring giving with flexible scheduling

- Peer-to-peer fundraising campaigns

- Crowdfunding pages for special projects

- Text-to-give functionality

- Multiple payment processor options (Stripe, PayPal)

- Donor management with CRM features

- Customizable giving pages and pop-up forms

- Multi-currency international giving support

- Automated tax receipts and statements

Standout Strength

Fundraising versatility that church-specific platforms lack. Donorbox supports building campaigns, mission trip fundraising, and community projects alongside regular tithing, providing tools that Pushpay's weekly-giving focus does not address.

Best For

Churches running capital campaigns, mission projects, or community fundraising alongside regular giving, and organizations needing flexible fundraising beyond standard tithing.

Pricing Overview

- Free plan for basic features (up to $1,000 per month)

- Standard plan approximately $45 per month

- Pro plan with advanced features at higher tiers

- Transaction fees via Stripe or PayPal rates

- No long-term contracts

Limitations

- Not designed specifically for church giving workflows.

- No branded church app or ChMS features.

- Lacks church-specific terminology and fund management.

Quick Comparison Insight

More fundraising flexibility than Pushpay with campaign tools, at dramatically lower cost, but less church-specific in design.

Stripe (for Churches)

Overview

Stripe provides the payment infrastructure that powers many church giving platforms, including elements of Tithe.ly and others. Using Stripe directly eliminates the giving platform markup on transaction fees. For churches with technical resources or website platforms that integrate Stripe natively, direct implementation provides the lowest possible processing costs.

This approach trades Pushpay's polished giving experience for maximum cost efficiency, requiring churches to build or configure their own donation forms rather than using a turnkey solution.

Core Capabilities

- Payment processing for cards and ACH transfers

- Recurring payment scheduling via Stripe Billing

- Custom donation forms through Stripe Elements

- Invoicing for pledge management

- Detailed financial reporting and analytics

- Webhook integrations for automated workflows

- Multi-currency international payment support

- PCI-compliant payment infrastructure

- Developer API for custom integrations

- Volume-based pricing for high-volume processors

Standout Strength

Lowest base processing rates without any platform markup. Stripe eliminates the intermediary cost layer that every church giving platform, including Pushpay, adds on top of base payment processing fees.

Best For

Technically capable churches with development resources wanting to minimize processing costs, especially high-volume churches where fee savings compound significantly.

Pricing Overview

- No monthly subscription fee

- Standard card processing: 2.9% plus $0.30

- ACH processing: 0.80% with $5 cap per transaction

- Volume discounts available

- Custom pricing for large organizations

Limitations

- No church-specific features, donor management, or statements.

- Requires technical implementation.

- No text-to-give, church app, or branded giving experience.

Quick Comparison Insight

Lowest possible processing costs versus Pushpay's premium rates, but requires technical capability and provides zero church-specific functionality.

PayPal (for Churches)

Overview

PayPal provides universal donor recognition that eliminates the adoption friction Pushpay addresses through its optimized onboarding flows. Nearly every potential donor already has a PayPal account. Combined with Venmo integration for younger donors and QR code giving for in-service donations, PayPal offers familiar data privacy and payment infrastructure that donors trust immediately.

For churches where donor convenience outweighs advanced analytics, PayPal's ubiquity provides adoption rates that purpose-built platforms achieve through engineering.

Core Capabilities

- Donation buttons and embeddable giving forms

- PayPal Checkout with familiar donor experience

- Recurring donation scheduling

- PayPal.me links for simple sharing

- Venmo integration for younger donors

- QR code giving for in-service donations

- Donor email receipts and records

- Multi-currency international payment support

- Mobile and desktop payment processing

- Universal website platform compatibility

Standout Strength

Universal brand recognition that provides instant donor trust. PayPal eliminates the need for Pushpay's sophisticated onboarding optimization by leveraging existing accounts that donors already trust and use.

Best For

Churches prioritizing donor convenience, international congregations, and churches wanting supplemental giving alongside a primary platform.

Pricing Overview

- No monthly subscription for basic donation features

- Standard processing: 2.89% plus $0.49 per transaction

- Nonprofit rates: 1.99% plus $0.49 for qualified organizations

- PayPal Giving Fund: 0% fees for registered charities

- No contracts required

Limitations

- No church-specific donor management or giving statements.

- No recurring giving optimization tools.

- Fee structure less transparent than dedicated giving platforms.

Quick Comparison Insight

Donor familiarity that eliminates Pushpay's onboarding challenge at zero commitment cost, but no church-specific features or analytics.

Breeze ChMS (Giving)

Overview

Breeze includes giving alongside church management, connecting donor data to member records, attendance, and groups in one simple platform. For small churches that found Pushpay's standalone giving excessive, Breeze provides giving plus management through the most user-friendly interface in church technology.

The flat-rate pricing includes everything: member management, giving, events, communication, and volunteer tools. No module charges, no per-transaction subscription fees, no contracts. Staff onboarding is straightforward, since the same database that tracks members also handles contributions.

Core Capabilities

- Online giving with branded donation forms

- Text-to-give functionality

- Recurring donations with automated scheduling

- Contribution tracking with fund management

- Batch entry for cash and check donations

- Donor statements and year-end tax receipts

- Giving reports and analytics dashboards

- Integrated with Breeze member database

- Mobile-responsive giving experience

- Donor-covers-fees option

Standout Strength

Giving integrated with the simplest church management platform at a predictable flat rate. Breeze provides management plus giving for less than Pushpay charges for giving alone.

Best For

Small to mid-size churches (50 to 500 members) that want giving and management in one affordable, simple platform.

Pricing Overview

- Flat rate approximately $72 to $100 per month (includes all features)

- Standard processing fees apply

- No module charges or per-feature pricing

- No long-term contracts

- Unlimited users and records

Limitations

- Giving features are less specialized than Pushpay.

- No custom church app or advanced donor analytics.

- Basic giving reports compared to premium platforms.

Quick Comparison Insight

Management plus giving for less than Pushpay's giving-only subscription, with dramatically simpler adoption but no advanced donor tools.

Where Teachfloor Fits

The tools above handle Pushpay. To actually build, deliver, and manage the courses or training programs around them, you need a learning platform. Teachfloor is a flexible course and training platform: run programs self-paced, social, live, or in cohorts, with built-in community, peer review, AI course creation, certificates, and white-label branding on your own domain. It pairs well with the tools on this list, hosting and structuring the learning experience around them.

If you are choosing a home for your courses rather than a single-purpose tool, Teachfloor is worth a look. It starts at $89 per month with a 14-day free trial.

How to Choose the Right Pushpay Alternative

Match your selection to what matters most after leaving Pushpay's premium tier.

If lowest transaction costs matter, Planning Center Giving provides the lowest rates with no monthly subscription. Stripe direct provides the lowest base rates for technically capable churches.

If branded app quality matters, Subsplash delivers Pushpay-comparable custom apps at more accessible pricing. Tithe.ly provides a budget app builder with giving included.

If simplicity and zero commitment matter, Givelify provides mobile giving with no monthly fees and no contracts. PayPal provides universal donor familiarity.

If all-in-one value matters, Tithe.ly bundles giving, app, website, ChMS, and media at a fraction of Pushpay's cost. Breeze provides giving plus management at a flat rate.

If fundraising versatility matters, Donorbox offers peer-to-peer and crowdfunding tools that Pushpay's tithing focus does not address.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will switching from Pushpay reduce my church's giving?

Short-term, any platform transition creates temporary friction that may affect giving. Long-term, churches that switch to platforms with lower fees often net more revenue despite slightly lower gross giving, because the processing cost savings compound. Communicate the transition clearly to your congregation and provide straightforward instructions for setting up recurring gifts on the new platform.

What is the closest alternative to Pushpay in quality?

Subsplash provides the closest match in branded app quality and giving experience at a lower price point. Planning Center Giving provides the cleanest giving UX with the lowest fees but without a custom branded app.

Can small churches benefit from Pushpay alternatives?

Small churches benefit most from leaving Pushpay. The premium pricing rarely generates ROI below 300 members. Planning Center Giving (free module, lowest fees), Givelify (zero monthly cost), and Breeze (giving plus management at flat rate) all provide more cost-appropriate solutions.

Should I wait until my Pushpay contract ends to switch?

Yes. Review your contract for the renewal date and required cancellation notice period. Begin evaluating alternatives six months before contract end. Request data exports from Pushpay well in advance. Most churches should not pay early termination fees when the contract will expire naturally.